FDA: Mercury Fillings Not Harmful
FDA Rules Mercury in Dental Fillings Doesn't Cause Harm, but Tightens Controls
July 28, 2009 -- The mercury used in dental amalgam fillings is not at a level high enough to cause harm in patients, according to the FDA, which today issued its final regulation on the controversial tooth filling material.
However, the agency tightened its controls on mercury fillings, classifying the encapsulated amalgams now commonly sold to dentists as Class II devices, deemed a moderate risk, instead of the lower risk Class I devices.
Dental amalgams, the silver-colored material used to fill teeth after removal of a cavity, include liquid mercury and a powder that contains silver, tin, copper, zinc, and other metals. When the fillings are placed in the teeth or removed, or during chewing, mercury vapor is released, according to the FDA. At high levels, mercury can cause adverse health effects to the brain and kidneys.
A representative from an organization that opposes mercury fillings called the new ruling "an outrage," while the American Dental Association issued a statement agreeing with the decision.
FDA's Final Rule on Amalgams
At a media advisory to announce the final rule, the FDA's Susan Runner, DDS, said, ''The best available scientific evidence supports the conclusion that patients with dental amalgam fillings are not at risk for mercury-associated adverse health effects.
''Long-term clinical studies in adults and children age 6 and older with dental amalgam fillings have not established a causal link between dental amalgam fillings and adverse health effects,'' says Runner, the agency's acting director of the Division of Anesthesiology, General Hospital, Infection Control, and Dental Devices in the Center for Devices and Radiological Health.
The scientific evidence on the effects of mercury fillings on developing fetuses and children younger than age 6 is limited, she says, but "the scientific evidence that is available suggests these populations also are not at risk."
Over the past 20 years, according to Runner, the FDA has received 141 adverse event reports regarding dental amalgams, with none resulting in death.
Tuesday's action comes about a year after the agency agreed to issue a final rule after being sued by consumer groups and individuals concerned about the health effects of mercury exposure.