How to Get Your Kids to Behave
Surprise. You might first have to change your own behavior.
I am no Captain von Trapp and yet, as the mother of 21-month-old twins,
there lurks within me a certain envy of how the "Sound of Music"
patriarch managed his brood. In the movie's party scene, his seven neatly
outfitted children serenade a charmed group of guests, then march off to their
rooms for bed. My kids are too young to march and just last week they mutinied
out of their high chairs, climbed onto the kitchen table, and flung around wads
of raisin toast, without so much as a chorus of "My Favorite Things."
Stunned, overwhelmed, and prematurely fatigued, I was left once again to
consider my disciplinary failings.
And that may have been my first mistake.
According to a new breed of discipline experts, parents who flail themselves
for not being able to control their toddlers and make them do what they should
do, for heaven's sake, might be better off taking a fresh look at the whole
parent-child dynamic. Forget about time-outs, they say, forget about punishment
entirely. These experts advocate no begging, no manipulation, no threats, no
giving up -- and they're not talking about the kids, they're talking about how
the parents behave. That's the gist of this more gentle approach to
discipline: if parents can teach themselves to act assertively, kindly, and
responsibly, they have a good chance of teaching their children to do the
While time-outs were designed as a way to let a child cool off by himself
and face the consequences of misbehaving, these experts say placing an angry
child alone is needlessly harsh. "What does a time-out do?" asks Martha
Heineman Pieper, PhD, co-author of Smart Love. "It teaches children
that when they're upset, you don't want to be around them." Her suggestion:
"Say, 'I'm sorry you feel bad. I'll sit here with you until you feel
Jane Nelsen, Ed.D., author of Positive Discipline for Pre-Schoolers,
concurs. It's misguided to think that a child will go to her room and think
about what she's done wrong, says Nelsen. "The child's thinking about how
not to get caught next time or, worse, that she's a bad person."