Medically Reviewed by Gabriela Pichardo, MD on May 17, 2020
Worst (and Best) Cities for Smog

Worst (and Best) Cities for Smog

1/18

2021 marks the 51st year of America’s Clean Air Act, a law passed to improve air quality. But more than half a century later, many U.S. cities still have unhealthy levels of smog, according to the American Lung Association’s annual State of the Air rankings. Warming trends from climate change increase ozone and, along with frequent wildfires, worsen air quality.

No. 10: San Francisco

No. 10: San Francisco

2/18

Think of the Bay Area as a big bowl. Winds make it easy for polluted air to move from one valley to another. Vehicles driven by the nearly 9 million residents of San Francisco, San Jose, and Oakland play a role in the area’s dirty air. During warm months, residents can get daily updates on air quality from the Bay Area Air Quality Management District’s Spare the Air campaign.

No. 8 (Tie): Salt Lake City

No. 8 (Tie): Salt Lake City

3/18

Utah’s capital, along with most of the state’s population, is positioned in front of the Wasatch Mountains. In winter, temperature inversions -- a layer of high warm air aloft -- traps cooler air below. That means pollution created by the Salt Lake-Provo-Orem area’s 2.5 million residents has nowhere to go.

No. 8 (Tie): Denver

No. 8 (Tie): Denver

4/18

Colorado is working to meet a June 2021 EPA compliance deadline for lowering ground ozone levels. Strict oil and gas regulations helped, as did having fewer of the Denver-Aurora metro area’s 3.6 million residents on the road during the COVID-19 pandemic. But rising temperatures and drier weather have also led to a jump in wildfires throughout the state.

No. 7: San Diego, CA

No. 7: San Diego, CA

5/18

The San Diego-Chula Vista-Carlsbad metro area scored an F on this year’s ozone report, with more than 100 days of high readings. The toxic air is bad news for the metro area’s more than 300,000 kids and adults with some form of asthma.

No. 6: Sacramento, CA

No. 6: Sacramento, CA

6/18

The Sacramento Valley is shaped like a bowl. In summer, pollutants like exhaust from cars get trapped closer to the ground. The Sacramento-Roseville metro area, home to 2.6 million, earned a spot on the lists for highest ozone days, most unhealthy spikes in particle pollution, and annual particle pollution levels. 

No. 5: Phoenix, AZ

No. 5: Phoenix, AZ

7/18

Arizona has less cloud cover than any other state. And Phoenix is the state’s second-sunniest city. More sunlight reaching the ground means more ozone. That could be why Phoenix moved up the list two spots from No. 7 last year. To clean things up, local leaders are working to curb the number of drivers on the road and to cap the use of wood-burning fire pits and fireworks.

No. 4: Fresno, CA

No. 4: Fresno, CA

8/18

The Fresno-Madera-Hanford metro area only has 1.3 million residents. They enjoyed the lowest number of ozone days since 2000, but stayed in the same spot on the list as last year. In addition to the number of cars on the road, geography is partly to blame. The bowl-shaped San Joaquin Valley traps vehicle emissions with no way for them to get out.

No. 3: Visalia, CA

No. 3: Visalia, CA

9/18

Things are looking up a bit in Visalia-Tulare County, which moved down the list one spot from last year’s second-place ranking for ozone. It stayed in third place, though, for year-round air particle pollution. Tulare County, located in California’s San Joaquin Valley, is home to only about 460,000 people but more than 1 million cattle. Industrial dairies play a big part in local air pollution, which includes high levels of methane emissions.

No. 2: Bakersfield, CA

No. 2: Bakersfield, CA

10/18

Unlike other cities in California’s smog-trapping San Joaquin Valley, Bakersfield can blame some of its air pollution on oil and gas production. It’s no surprise the area ranked first for particle pollution. One local company admitted to violating the Clean Air Act for greenhouse gas emissions. And the city has some 40,000 residents with heart disease. All that smoggy air can increase their odds of having a heart attack.

No. 1: Los Angeles

No. 1: Los Angeles

11/18

2021’s smog capital is the Los Angeles-Long Beach metro area, home to 18.7 million people. The city’s crowded freeways definitely play a role in creating ozone levels, but LA’s famous sunny weather doesn’t help. Sunshine ramps up smog levels, aggravating symptoms for the 1.5 million residents who have some form of asthma.

Bakersfield, CA, and Year-Round Particle Pollution

Bakersfield, CA, and Year-Round Particle Pollution

12/18

This California city once again claims the No. 1 spot when it comes to year-round particle pollution, or soot. High rankings are nothing new for Bakersfield, which led this category from 2016 to 2018. Locals point to oil and gas production facilities, along with its location in the San Joaquin Valley, which traps pollution and holds it in. Wildfires also raised soot levels across the Western U.S.

Cleanest Cities

Cleanest Cities

13/18

Five cities ranked highest in the U.S. for the three measures of clean air: ozone, year-round particle pollution, and short-term particle pollution in 2021. Three repeated this honor 2 years in a row. That’s good news for residents: People who live in cities with good air quality may live longer, healthier lives.

Burlington, VT

Burlington, VT

14/18

Located near the U.S.-Canada border, Burlington is home to 279,000 residents who enjoy fresh, grade-A air. An overall lack of heavy industry coupled with fewer automobiles -- two leading sources of air pollution -- could be why. 

Charlottesville, VA

Charlottesville, VA

15/18

History-packed Charlottesville is home to a little over 200,000 people and the University of Virginia. You’ll also find the Shenandoah National Park, part of the Blue Ridge Mountains. Residents enjoy outdoor activities like hiking, rafting, and skydiving into the smog and soot-free air.

Elmira-Corning, NY

Elmira-Corning, NY

16/18

Nearly 200,000 people call this metro area home. Located on the edge of New York’s Finger Lakes region, it offers wineries, rolling hills, hiking trails, and plenty of fishing spots. You can even find the Victorian home sites that inspired much of Mark Twain's work. What you won’t find is a lot of dirty air. Elmira-Corning ranked 7th on this year’s list of cleanest cities for year-round particle pollution.

Honolulu

Honolulu

17/18

Once again, Honolulu took top honors for lowest annual particle pollution levels. That means nearly 1 million people who call this tropical city home are breathing some of the nation’s cleanest air. Credit goes in part to the weather -- year-round winds and rain play a role -- as does a lack of heavy industry.

Wilmington, NC

Wilmington, NC

18/18

Home to 297,000 residents, this Atlantic Ocean beach community had no unhealthy air quality days from ozone, or long- or short-term particle pollution. North Carolina is also focusing on clean power research, sinking billions into solar and wind energy projects.

Show Sources

IMAGES PROVIDED BY:

  1. HotPhotoPie / Getty Images
  2. Spondylolithesis / Getty Images
  3. 4kodiak / Getty Images
  4. Rudi Steenbruggen / Getty Images
  5. SeanPavonePhoto / Getty Images
  6. dszc / Getty Images
  7. dszc / Getty Images
  8. DenisTangneyJr / Getty Images
  9. DenisTangneyJr / Getty Images
  10. ChrisBoswell / Getty Images
  11. adamkaz / Getty Images
  12. DenisTangneyJr / Getty Images
  13. enter89 / Getty Images
  14. ErikaMitchell / Getty Images
  15. DenisTangneyJr / Getty Images
  16. DenisTangneyJr / Getty Images
  17. M Swiet Productions / Getty Images
  18. DenisTangneyJr / Getty Images

 

 

SOURCES:

American Lung Association: “Key Findings.” “State of the Air 2020,” “State of the Air 2021.”

 

News release, American Lung Association.

 

News release, Bay Area Air Quality Management District.

 

Utah Live Elevated: “Wasatch Mountains.”

 

The Colorado Sun: “Air quality improved slightly during the stay-at-home order. But Colorado still has a serious pollution problem.”

 

CPR News: “Colorado Wildfires Are Climate Change ‘In The Here And Now’ — And A Sign Of Summers To Come”

 

Sacramento State: “Air Quality at Sacramento State.”

 

News release, Arizona Department of Environmental Quality.

 

ABC 30 Action News: “Central CA has some of the most polluted cities in the nation, report says.”

 

The Fresno Bee: “Report ranks best and worst cities for air quality. Any guess where Fresno landed on the list?”

 

News release, Center for Biological Diversity.

 

United States Environmental Protection Agency: “EPA Activities for Cleaner Air.”

 

USA Today: “Over 4 of 10 Americans breathe polluted air, report says. And people of color are 61% more likely to be affected.”

 

Vermont Department of Health: “TRACKING AIR QUALITY IN VERMONT.”

 

Visit Charlottesville: “At Our Parks - Shenandoah National Park,” “History of Charlottesville and Albemarle County,” “Outdoor Adventure.”

 

New York’s Finger Lakes Tourism Alliance: Chemung County.”

 

University of Hawaii Department of Geology & Geophysics: “Ask an Earth Scientist.”

 

StarNews Online: “What cat pee smell? Wilmington's air quality rated among the best in United States.”

 

WHQR Public Media: “Offshore wind energy.”