Older Patients May Lose Voice Quality Over Time, Naturally
WebMD News Archive
Nov. 22, 1999 (Atlanta) -- A quiver in the voice, a loss of vocal strength,
perhaps a change in pitch. These may all be normal changes in a person's voice
as they age. But then again, maybe they're not, and it could be important to
know the difference, especially if the change signals an underlying medical
A new study presented at the annual meeting of the American
Speech-Language-Hearing Association, held in San Francisco, finds that updated
norms may be needed for speech pathologists to effectively test elderly
patients in the brave new world of digital technology.
The study's lead author, Steve Xue, PhD, assistant professor of hearing and
speech sciences at Ohio University, tells WebMD that current standards for
voice testing are based on young and middle-aged people. "This study showed
that if you are an elderly patient, especially ... over age 70, your noise
level may be quite normal for your age group. But those [current] tests will
show that it's abnormal, so the current problem in our field is we use young or
middle-aged people as yardsticks to measure those clients of different age
groups, including those over 70," Xue says.
The study put 21 men and 23 women between the ages of 70 and 80 through
tests that used digital equipment that measured 15 different acoustic
parameters, covering frequency, pitch, tone, and other vocal characteristics.
None of the group had smoked or had neurological damage or speech disorders in
the last five years. The results were then compared with published norms of
young and middle-aged adults. The researchers found the elderly participants
had significantly poorer vocal quality when compared to younger people.
The elderly participants had a harder time keeping a stable tone, and some
voices were harsher or more hoarse. Xue also pointed out that for some women,
their voices get deeper as they age, whereas for some men, their voices get
higher as they age. Without the proper norms in place, Xue tells WebMD it is
likely some speech pathologists could make mistakes or misdiagnoses.
Xue pointed to two reasons for the study. First, there's a large increase in
the elderly population in the U.S., leading to more speech-language
pathologists with elderly patients. And second: "[New] digital technology
will enable us to make very detailed measurements, so if we use thresholds from
30- or 40-year-olds, then apply them to a 70-year-old client, the testing
results will be quite different, abnormal here and there, but then you realize
maybe aging is the real cause," Xue tells WebMD.
Digital equipment is central to this issue. Richard K. Adler, PhD, CCCSLP, a
clinical language speech pathologist, acknowledges that updated norms could
help clinicians using the new digital equipment. But that equipment is
expensive, and he says generally just used by hospitals and research labs at
this point. Using more traditional methods, Adler says he doesn't necessarily
compare his patients to a set of norms.