Many Women Misunderstand Pap Tests
Survey Shows Confusion Over Meaning of Results
May 9, 2006 (Washington) -- Many women do not know what a Pap test is, a new
And a second study suggests that many teens do not consider oral sex to be
"While Pap test screening has decreased the number of deaths from cervical
cancer by 70%, misconceptions persist," says researcher Raksha
Joshi, MBA, of Monmouth Family Health Center in Aberdeen, N.J.
Previous research has shown that two-thirds of teens and young adults think
the Pap test is the same as a pelvic exam, Joshi says.
In fact, the Pap test, also called a Pap smear, is most often performed as
part of a routine gynecologic exam. Named for George Papanicolaou, the doctor
who designed the test, the Pap test takes a sample of cells from the cervix; it
can detect early abnormal cell changes that could lead to cervical cancer.
Pap Test Survey
For the new survey, presented at the annual meeting of the American College
of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, the researchers asked 351 women seven basic
questions about the Pap test.
A total of 192 of the women completed the questionnaire in English, while
159 completed it in Spanish.
Among the findings:
- Only about half of the English-speaking women and two-thirds of the Spanish
speakers knew that the Pap test is not used to detect gonorrhea or chlamydia.
- About half of the women in both groups mistakenly thought that they would
definitely have cancer if their doctor tells them their Pap test is not normal.
In truth, an abnormal Pap test result is not uncommon because the cells of the
cervix normally undergo constant change. But not all of these abnormal results
indicate changes that are cancer or precancerous.
- Nearly half of women in both groups mistakenly thought they would need a
hysterectomy if their Pap test is not normal.
- Only one-third of the Spanish speakers and two-thirds of the English
speakers knew the test is performed to detect cancer of the cervix. Of those
women who answered incorrectly, most thought the test was used to check for
cancer of the uterus, Joshi says.
The Youth Perspective
The second survey, of 1,050 teens and young adults, showed that nearly 60%
had engaged in "hooking up" -- a phrase used to describe one-time
sexual encounters that involve anything from kissing to intercourse.
But of the health care professionals surveyed, only 52% had ever heard of
"hooking up," says researcher Alexandria J. George, DO, of Lehigh
Valley Hospital in Wescosville, Pa.
Of those who did hook up, half engaged in oral sex, she says.
What was disturbing, George says, is that "there is evidence the young
people think oral sex is not sex."
For example, one young woman who responded to the survey said she didn't
need protection from sexually transmitted diseases because she didn't really
have sex, she says.