Traditional vs. Precision Medicine: How They Differ

Traditional medicine and precision medicine are two approaches doctors use to treat disease. They work in different ways.

Traditional medicine follows a one-size-fits-all approach. Drugs and other therapies are designed to treat large groups of people with the same disease -- like diabetes or cancer. They may factor in your sex, age, or weight, but overall, doctors base your treatment on what’s most likely to work for everyone with a similar illness.

But not everyone responds to a treatment in the same way. Some drugs work very well for certain people. Others don’t help at all or cause harmful side effects. Finding the exact drug that works for you can involve a lot of trial and error.

Precision medicine takes things a step further. Doctors use information about you -- your genes, lifestyle, and environment -- along with the characteristics of your disease to select treatments that are most likely to work for you. Because it’s so closely tied to who you are, precision medicine is sometimes called personalized medicine.

One current use for this is a targeted therapy to treat a specific type of cancer cell, like those in HER2-positive breast cancer.

How Does Precision Medicine Work?

In traditional medicine, scientists develop drugs to treat the symptoms or the disease itself. They test the drugs in clinical trials that involve large groups of people who have that disease. The FDA approves a new drug when studies show that its benefits outweigh its risks. That means people who take it will do better with it and won’t be hurt by it. Yet that doesn't mean the medicine will help everyone who takes it.

Precision medicine is much more targeted. Over years of research, scientists have learned more about the genetics behind how diseases start and how they behave.

Many diseases are linked to gene changes. Thanks to the Human Genome Project, researchers now have a map of all the genes in the human body. They can see how certain gene changes cause disease and what makes one person's heart disease, diabetes, or cancer act differently from another's. Knowing how genes and diseases interact can help them fine-tune treatments to make them work better.

For example, we now know that certain gene changes make some cancers grow faster than others. Targeting these changes makes personalized medicine a much more precise and effective way to slow or stop cancer.

Continued

How Can Precision Medicine Help?

Doctors can use precision medicine to:

  • Learn your disease risk. Testing your genes can reveal which conditions run in your family and how likely you are to get them.
  • Prevent disease. Once you know you carry a certain gene, you may be able to make lifestyle changes or get medical treatment so you don’t get sick. For example, women who carry the BRCA1 or BRCA2 gene mutation are at higher risk for breast cancer. To lower their risk, they may choose to have surgery to remove a breast, called a mastectomy.
  • Find disease. If you know you're at risk for a certain disease, you can get tested for it. The earlier you find diseases like cancer, the easier they are to treat.
  • Target treatments. Your genetic makeup can help guide your doctor to the drug that’s most likely to work for you and cause the fewest side effects. Precision medicine can even help you decide what dose of a drug you should take.
  • Monitor your response. Doctors can use precision medicine techniques to see how well your condition responds to a treatment.

What Are the Benefits of Precision Medicine?

Precision medicine has a few benefits over traditional medicine.

  1. It can do more. The primary aim of traditional medicine is to treat symptoms of a disease once they start. The goals of precision medicine are to predict, prevent, and treat disease.
  2. It's more accurate. Drugs and other traditional medicine treatments are created for and tested on large groups of people. Because they're prescribed so broadly, they don't work for everyone. The average prescription drug may not work well for all the people who take it. Precision medicine can predict which treatment will work best for you because it's targeted to your condition and genes. So a precision drug is far more likely to be effective against your disease than a drug that treats everyone in the same way.
  3. It makes side effects less likely. Any drug you take has risks. What makes precision medicine better is that targeted drugs act directly on the disease. They don’t affect your entire body. And because you're more likely to find the right drug the first time, you won't have to take as many medicines. The fewer drugs you take, the lower the odds of side effects.

Continued

When Will Precision Medicine Become Available?

Precision medicine isn't in the distant future. Some examples of treatments already in use today include:

  • Before a blood transfusion, doctors match the donor's blood to the recipient's to make sure the two are compatible.
  • Trastuzumab (Herceptin), a breast cancer drug, is designed to treat women whose tumors have a protein called HER2.
  • The drugs cetuximab (Erbitux) and panitumumab (Vectibix) target epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR), a protein on the surface of some colon cancer cells that helps the cancer grow.
  • A gene test can predict whether people who receive a heart transplant will reject the transplanted organ.

Researchers continue to collect more and more data about our genes and habits and learn how they interact to affect our health. Thanks to advances in personalized medicine, in the future doctors will be better able to predict whether we'll get sick and to find just the right treatment if we do.

WebMD Medical Reference Reviewed by Laura J. Martin, MD on June 09, 2019

Sources

SOURCES:

National Cancer Institute: "BRCA Mutations: Cancer Risk and Genetic Testing," “NCI Dictionary of Cancer Terms,” "Precision Medicine in Cancer Treatment."

The Jackson Laboratory: "What is Personalized Medicine?"

National Library of Medicine: "What is Precision Medicine?" "What is the difference between precision medicine and personalized medicine? What about pharmacogenomics?"

Journal of Biometrics & Biostatistics: "Some Thoughts on Precision Medicine."

FDA: "Development & Approval Process (Drugs)."

University of Utah: “More Examples of Precision Medicine in Action,” “Why the Time is Right."

American Cancer Society: "Targeted Therapy Drugs for Colorectal Cancer."

CDC: "Precision Medicine: What Does it Mean for Your Health?"

Grumezescu, A., editor. Nanostructures for the Engineering of Cells, Tissues and Organs: From Design to Application,” Elsevier, 2018.

Susan G. Komen: "Precision Medicine."

Personalized Medicine Coalition: "The Age of Personalized Medicine."

© 2019 WebMD, LLC. All rights reserved.

Pagination