Skip to content

Weight Loss & Diet Plans

Panel: CDC Study Wrong on Obesity Risk

Harvard experts say obesity death risk getting higher, not lower
Font Size
WebMD Weight Loss Clinic - Medical News

May 26, 2005 -- A CDC study underestimated U.S. obesity-related deaths and the death risk from being overweight, a Harvard panel says.

Just last month, CDC researchers Katherine M. Flegal, PhD, and colleagues suggested that the number of U.S. deaths directly linked to obesity is 112,000 per year. That's a lot lower than previous estimates of up to 400,000 annual obesity-related deaths.

Even more provocatively, the study showed no increased risk of death -- and even a slight protective effect -- for people who were merely overweight. And it showed that, perhaps because of medical advances, obesity is less likely to kill than in previous years.

Fiddlesticks, Harvard researchers said today at a highly publicized panel discussion held in Boston and webcast to the public. JoAnn Manson, MD, DrPH, professor of epidemiology at the Harvard School of Public Health, and colleagues went back over the same data used by the CDC researchers.

"It is biologically implausible that being overweight reduces mortality," says JoAnn Manson, MD, DrPH, professor of epidemiology at the Harvard School of Public Health. "We saw a very strong positive association with mortality -- a relative risk of [twofold] -- among those who were obese, and a clear increase in mortality among those who were overweight."

Also weighing in on the issue was Michael Thun, MD, vice president for epidemiology and surveillance research at the American Cancer Society in Atlanta.

"Overweight people do have higher all-cause death rates," Thun says. "This increase in mortality includes major cancers as well as cardiovascular disease. In my opinion, the CDC study seriously underestimated mortality from obesity and overweight."

The Method Is the Message

What's going on? Harvard and the American Cancer Society took a radically different approach to the data. Because smoking has a dramatic effect on health, they looked only at people who never smoked. And because undetected illness can make a person thin, they did not count deaths in the short term.

"Smoking masks the impact of obesity," says Frank Hu, MD, PhD, MPH, associate professor of nutrition and epidemiology at Harvard School of Public Health. "In our study there was no evidence of a reduced impact of obesity on mortality over time."

Researchers trying to determine the impact of obesity on death, Hu says, must exclude smokers and people who may be ill when the study begins. And, he says, it is very important for these studies to include very large numbers of people and to follow them for at least 20 years.

Today on WebMD

measuring waist
4 tips for shedding yours.
apple cider vinegar
Does it have health benefits?
Chocolate truffle
For weight loss, some aren’t so bad after all.
woman holding red dress
24 simple, practical tips.
woman shopping fresh produce
butter curl on knife
eating out healthy
Smiling woman, red hair
What Girls Need To Know About Eating Disorders
fat caliper

Special Sections