Do Flu Shots Save Lives?

One Study Shows a Large Impact, but Another Study Shows None

From the WebMD Archives

Feb. 14, 2005 - It is widely believed that getting a flu shot reduces deaths this time of year among the elderly by half or even more, but new research finds the lifesaving benefits of vaccination to be greatly overestimated.

Researchers from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) found no correlation between an increase in flu vaccine coverage over the past two decades and a decrease in influenza-related deaths among the elderly. Their conclusions contradict most other reported studies, including one published in the same Feb. 14 issue of the journal Archives of Internal Medicine.

In that study, researchers from the Netherlands reported that influenza vaccination was associated with a 50% reduction in deaths among people aged 65 and over. Vaccination was also credited with reducing deaths by 78% among younger, high-risk adults, such as those with chronic heart or lung diseases.

Coverage Has Increased

So which study is right? Noted flu vaccine expert William Schaffner, MD, says the truth probably lies somewhere in the middle.

The NIAID study was the first to examine flu deaths for the entire U.S. population rather than focusing on a selected group, as has been done in previous studies. Researcher Lone Simonsen, PhD, and colleagues used statistical models that tracked deaths due to pneumonia, influenza, and all other causes among the elderly from 1968 until 2001.

The percentage of elderly Americans who got annual flu shots rose steadily from around 15% before 1980 to 65% in 2001. Simonsen tells WebMD that the dramatic increase in coverage should have led to a dramatic drop in flu deaths.

"This is not what we found," she says. "Certainly if this intervention really does reduce winter deaths in the elderly by 50% we would expect to see it. So the mortality benefits are probably very much overestimated."

Simonsen says the 1997-1998 flu season perfectly illustrates the point. That year, the vaccine that was manufactured ended up being totally mismatched with the circulating flu strain, she says. So even though 63% of the eligible elderly got their flu shots, coverage was effectively zero.

Despite this, there were approximately 5,000 fewer excess deaths in this age group than there were the next flu season, when the same percentage of people were vaccinated and the vaccine did match the flu strain.

But Schaffner says the national data Simonsen and colleagues were forced to rely on were not comprehensive enough to give a true picture of the impact of vaccination on mortality.

"National record keeping is not precise enough in tracking illness, vaccination, and influenza diagnosis in the individual patient," he says. "We have not been able to show a mortality impact with vaccination, and that has been a source of frustration."

Schaffner says the smaller studies, like the one published along with the NIAID research, have consistently shown a decrease in seasonal deaths among elderly people who are vaccinated against the flu.

Eelko Hak, PhD, and colleagues from the Netherlands' University Medical Center Utrecht also reported a reduction in hospitalizations due to flu, pneumonia, or acute respiratory conditions among people aged 65 and over and among younger people at high risk for such conditions.

"Both patients and physicians should be convinced about the benefits of annual influenza vaccination, and no opportunities should be missed to have all patients recommended for vaccination against influenza," Hak tells WebMD.

Flu Shot Shortage Eases

The shortage of available flu vaccine dominated the news last fall, but recent figures from the CDC suggest that coverage rates among the elderly are just slightly lower than in a normal year.

In a statement released last week, the CDC estimated that approximately 3.5 million doses of flu vaccine are still available.

"Because February is often the most severe month of the influenza season and because influenza viruses might continue to circulate for several more weeks, it's not too late to benefit from vaccination this season," the statement notes.

Simonsen says the NIAID findings argue in favor of vaccinating everyone instead of just those at high risk for developing life-threatening complications from the flu. The theory is that universal vaccination would confer greater benefits for the elderly than targeted vaccinations.

"We totally agree that influenza is a major cause of serious illness, hospitalization, and death," she says. "Vaccinating the elderly is a major tool, but our findings suggest that there is more than can be done."

WebMD Health News


SOURCES: Simonsen, L. and Hak, E. Archives of Internal Medicine, Feb. 14, 2005; vol 165. pp 265-272, 274-280. Lone Simonsen, PhD, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Md. Eelko Hak, MSc, PhD, Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary Health Care, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands. William Schaffner, MD, chairman, department of preventive medicine, Vanderbilt University School of Medicine, Nashville, Tenn. Bonnie Hebert, spokeswoman, CDC. News release, CDC.
© 2005 WebMD, Inc. All rights reserved.
Click to view privacy policy and trust info