Does Second Opinion Sway Prostate Cancer Patients?

Most choose treatment they originally planned to follow, study finds

From the WebMD Archives

By Robert Preidt

HealthDay Reporter

MONDAY, Nov. 7, 2016 (HealthDay News) -- Second opinions have little impact on prostate cancer patients' treatment decisions, new research suggests.

The study included nearly 2,400 men in the Philadelphia area recently diagnosed with localized prostate cancer.

Forty percent of the men obtained a second opinion from urologists, most often because they wanted more information about their cancer (51 percent) or wanted to be seen by the best doctor (46 percent).

Overall, obtaining second opinions was not associated with changes in treatment choice or with improvements in how patients viewed their quality of cancer care.

The researchers also found that patients who obtained second opinions because they wanted more information, were seeking the best doctor, or had been encouraged to do so by family or friends were more likely to undergo surgery.

This suggests that for some men, second opinions offer a way to pursue the treatment they already planned on, rather than to explore other treatment options, according to study authors Dr. Archana Radhakrishnan, of Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, and her colleagues.

The study was published online Nov. 7 in the journal Cancer.