Skip to content
My WebMD Sign In, Sign Up

Depression Health Center

Font Size

New Shock Therapy Procedure Works With Fewer Side Effects

By
WebMD Health News

May 15, 2000 -- Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) can be an effective treatment for depression, particularly when other treatments have failed, but the memory loss associated with it makes some people afraid.

However, two new studies point to a new way to administer the treatment that achieves positive results similar to the traditional way, but with fewer bad side effects.

Traditional ECT usually requires that a shock be administered to both sides of the brain. But giving a higher level of shock to only the right side of the brain produces fewer memory problems and can be as effective as giving high-level shocks to both sides of the brain, according to the studies in the May issue of the Archives of General Psychiatry. The catch is that FDA regulations limit the amount of electricity that current equipment can produce to a level that is below the level researchers found to be most effective. Questions still remain about exactly which level of shock will produce the best effect.

The problem is that patients in older age groups, the group most patients fall into, need a high amount of shock to produce a good effect, according to Richard Abrams, MD, of the Chicago Medical School in Illinois. "Existing ECT devices cannot give enough electrical energy because of the limitations imposed upon them," says Abrams, who also is director of Somatics Inc., a company that manufactures and distributes ECT equipment.

Abrams wrote a commentary published in the same issue of the Archives of General Psychiatry in which he urges the FDA to act to allow high-stimulus ECT devices in the U.S. Such double-dose devices are routinely available in other parts of the world, including the United Kingdom, Canada, and Mexico.

"I agree with Abrams that the FDA has no scientific basis for limiting the output of ECT devices to the level they are now limited to. There's no justification for limiting the devices to the amount of energy arbitrarily established in 1984. ... The people in Europe and other parts of the world where they don't have that restriction really are better off," says Max Fink, MD, of Long Island Jewish Medical Center/Hillside Hospital in Queens, N.Y.

All those who spoke with WebMD reiterated the need for equipment that would allow high-intensity stimulation to the right side of the brain. A FDA spokesperson tells WebMD that the Center for Devices and Radiological Health has to review the relevant material and has no official response at this time.

In the first study, Harold A. Sackeim, PhD, and other investigators at the Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons in New York compared the effects of giving low, moderate, and high levels of shock to one side of depressed patients' brains, and giving a moderate level of shock to both sides. Depression and mental function were assessed before, immediately after, and two months after the treatment. Cognitive tests included an evaluation of different types of memory function, including the ability to remember events prior to treatment and after treatment. Patients were monitored for relapse for a year.

Today on WebMD

contemplation
Differences between feeling depressed or blue.
depressed man
How well are you managing your symptoms?
 
depressed man sitting on hallway floor
Learn the truth about this serious illness.
Sad woman looking out of the window
Tips to stay the treatment course.
 
Woman taking pill
Article
Woman jogging outside
Feature
 
man screaming
Article
woman standing behind curtains
Article
 
Pet scan depression
Slideshow
antidepressants slideshow
Article
 
pill bottle
Article
Winding path
Article