Posttraumatic Stress: 19% of Viet Vets
'Substantial' PTSD Rate Raises Concern for Iraq War Veterans
Aug. 17, 2006 -- Nearly one in five Vietnam veterans suffered posttraumatic stressstress disorder (PTSD) -- and nearly one in 10 was still suffering 11 to 12 years after the war, a new study finds.
That is fewer PTSD cases than once feared. But it is still a lot -- with implications for Iraq war veterans, find Columbia researcher Bruce P. Dohrenwend, PhD, and colleagues.
"Substantial similarities exist between Vietnam then and Iraq now," Dohrenwend and colleagues note. "Both have been wars without fronts, in which it is often difficult to tell peaceful civilians from enemy combatants."
The study appears in the Aug. 18 issue of the journal Science.
Long after a life-threatening event, PTSD can cause flashbacks -- vivid, disturbing memories of the trauma -- as well as sleep problems, nightmares, and panic attackspanic attacks. People with PTSD may feel detached, guilty, or paranoid. They often suffer depressiondepression and are at increased risk of suicide.
In the 1980s, it became apparent that many Vietnam veterans were suffering PTSD symptoms. Exactly how many was controversial. There were charges that some of these veterans were claiming to have PTSD in order to get undeserved disability benefits.
In 1988, there were two conflicting studies. The CDC said that about 15% of veterans ever had PTSD, and only about 2% still had it. The National Vietnam Veterans' Readjustment Study (NVVRS) found that 31% of Vietnam vets suffered PTSD, with 15% still suffering -- seven times the CDC's estimate.
Dohrenwend and colleagues did something neither the CDC nor the NVVRS did. They developed a measure of veterans' probable severity of exposure to war-zone stress. To do this, they analyzed military personnel data along with data from military archives and historical records.
The researchers reanalyzed the NVVRS data.
- The NVVRS overestimated PTSD rates and the CDC underestimated PTSD rates.
- There was very little evidence of veterans falsely claiming to have PTSD.
- "Substantial" numbers of Vietnam veterans suffered PTSD: 18.7% of all Vietnam veterans.
- As of 1990, 9.1% of all Vietnam veterans still suffered PTSD.
- The more war trauma a veteran experienced, the higher that veteran's odds of having PTSD.
- Most veterans who experienced very highly traumatic events did not develop PTSD.
"We found little evidence of falsification by veterans, an even stronger dose-response relationship than previously reported, and substantial adverse psychological consequences of the Vietnam war," Dohrenwend said in a news release. "Although our study points to resiliency of most veterans, the findings highlight the need for further research on [long-lasting psychological problems] in victims of war-related trauma."
In an editorial accompanying the Dohrenwend study, Harvard anxiety-disorder expert Richard J. McNally, PhD, praises the researchers for their solid scientific work in an emotion-charged area of research.
He also notes that the PTSD issue is far from over for America's veterans. From 1999 to 2004, he notes, the number of veterans receiving disability compensation for PTSD increased by nearly 80%.
"Does this indicate an upsurge of delayed-onset PTSD, a reactivation of symptoms among veterans approaching retirement, or delayed presentation of PTSD among those who have suffered for decades and are only now seeking the help they need?" he asks.