CRP Tests: No News We Can Use?
Study Questions Routine CRP Test for Heart-Disease Risk
WebMD News Archive
Why CRP Is Important continued...
"Because there is a constant infusion of fat particles into the artery wall, the inflammation never goes away," Tracy tells WebMD. "If the blood-fat concentration is high enough, this essentially swamps the system. ... So it is not the fat in the artery that is the problem, it is the immune response to that."
And CRP is, at the moment, the best way to measure this deadly immune response. But since CRP levels are linked to traditional risk factors, Tracy agrees with Miller that not everyone needs a CRP test.
"My opinion is that the public is still best served by finding risk factors a person can work on," Tracy says. "For some people, obesity might be the main risk. For others it might be a high LDL cholesterol level. While knowing CRP and cholesterol ratios might help define the risk, you will have lost the information about the source of the increased inflammation."
Not so fast, says heart disease expert Ishwarlal Jialal, MD, PhD, director of the laboratory for atherosclerosis and metabolic research at the University of California, Davis.
Jialal notes that the Miller study used a relatively insensitive CRP test. This, he says, likely missed a lot of people with dangerous CRP levels but only borderline traditional risk factors. If these people had their CRP measured by current methods, their doctors would be more likely to advise immediate action.
Moreover, Jialal says, monitoring CRP would tell doctors how well treatment -- lifestyle change and treatment with cholesterol-lowering drugs -- is working.
"If you only look at cholesterol and blood fats, you miss the additional risk that CRP portends," Jialal tells WebMD. "CRP is important. And recent studies show when you lower CRP and LDL cholesterol, you have a greater benefit than lowering LDL alone."
More Heart-Risk Tests On the Way
Tracy says there's another reason not to put too many eggs in the CRP basket. CRP, he notes, is only one of thousands of blood proteins involved in heart disease.
Researchers now are beginning to translate the eloquent language spoken by these chemical messengers. Until more is known, Tracy says, it's not a good idea to bet scarce public-health dollars on the first horse in the race.
"We are making huge strides in understanding this disease," Tracy says. "We should be prepared to change as our knowledge explodes. With this will come new methods for the prediction, diagnosis, and treatment of heart disease. So let's keep the enthusiasm, and use CRP wisely when it really can help doctors make a change for a patient. And let's keep our ears to the ground for the changes that will happen in the next five to 10 years."