New Guidelines for Osteoporosis Tests
Older Men and Younger Men With Risk Factors Should Get Bone Density Test
Feb. 21, 2008 -- For the first time, the nation's leading osteoporosis group
is recommending routine bone density testing for men as well as women.
New guidelines released Thursday by the National Osteoporosis Foundation
(NOF) call for bone mineral density (BMD) testing for all men ages 70 and older
and for younger men with risk factors for bone loss.
Testing is also recommended for all women ages 65 and older, as well as
younger, postmenopausal women with risk factors for osteoporosis.
NOF officials also unveiled a new method for identifying people at high risk
for developing osteoporosis and suffering fractures, which they called a major
breakthrough for determining who should and should not be treated.
More than half of fractures related to bone loss occur in people who do not
yet have osteoporosis but have a borderline condition of low bone mass called
An estimated 10 million Americans have osteoporosis, but three times as many
are believed to have osteopenia.
Until now, clinicians have had no clear guidelines for assessing fracture
risk in these patients, NOF President Ethel Siris, MD, tells WebMD.
"We haven't really had a good way of determining which osteopenic
patients are high risk and should be treated and which are low risk and may not
need treatment," she says.
Assessing Fracture Risk
The guideline is based on a new 10-year fracture probability model developed
by the World Health Organization (WHO).
The model was developed using risk assessment data from studies largely
conducted within the last decade involving some 60,000 people.
"We have learned a lot over the last 10 years about which risk factors
are important for determining fracture risk," osteoporosis specialist
Robert Lindsay, MD, PhD, said in a Thursday afternoon news conference. Lindsay
served on the NOF committee that wrote the new clinician's guide.
Those risk factors include:
- Gender and age
- Suffering a previous fracture
- Being underweight
- Use of oral steroids
- Having a parent who suffered a hip fracture
- Being a smoker
- Drinking alcohol in excess
Other factors such as having rheumatoid
arthritis or any autoimmune disease, getting little or no exercise, and not getting enough calcium and vitamin D can
also contribute to fracture risk.
The WHO model is designed to determine a person's risk of suffering a
fracture within 10 years, based on the results of bone density testing and risk
The new guidelines call for treatment to be offered to anyone with low bone
mass and whose 10-year risk for suffering a hip fracture exceeds 3% or whose
risk for any fracture related to bone loss exceeds 20%, Siris says.
"That doesn't mean people should not be treated if their risk does not
meet this threshold," Siris says. "But it makes it very clear that
above this threshold it is medically proper and cost-effective to treat these
Fractures related to osteoporosis and bone loss cost the U.S. health care
system an estimated $17 billion in 2005, and this cost is projected to double
or even triple over the next 20 to 30 years as the population ages.
Having better ways of identifying patients who would benefit from treatment
could save health care dollars by reducing fractures and allowing low-risk
patients to avoid unnecessary treatments, Siris says.